Thursday, December 15, 2011

Spot the error(s)--a geography lesson

At the pediatrician today, I had to fill out a form about Eggbert. All was fairly routine until I ran into the following question:

"Race/ethnicity. Check ONE box [emphasis in original]:

White/caucasian___ African-American___ Native American___ Hispanic___ Other____"

Now color me sensitive (what, me?), but I think that asking a child to choose to acknowledge only one side of their ethnic heritage is wrong wrong wrong. It's like saying who do you love more, mommy or daddy?

Also, I have to wonder if they teach you about the existence of this place in doctor school. I heard it's kind of big and a lot of people live there, and the last time I checked, it wasn't called "Other."

4 comments:

China Doll said...

Unbelievable!!

Antropóloga said...

Jeez, seems like the practice would be more likely to have kids with Asian heritage than Native American. I mean, if they were listing fewer options to save space or something. Did you say anything?

Sara said...

Yes, I said "what box are Asians supposed to check" and the receptionist rather snippily said "that's 'Other'!"

JENN said...

I just hate, hate, hate that box-checking question (systemic racism). How does that help a Dr with medical history if they don't have the full story? I usually ignore the question. When asked, I just say, "We don't belong in any of those boxes".